DOI: 10.63565/journal.scipinion
Publication Date: November, 2025
Iteration: Volume 1, issue 3 (Fall 2025)
Where Scientific Truth Emerges Through Expert Consensus
The SciPinion Collective Wisdom Hub serves as a central repository for objective scientific knowledge derived from our global community of verified experts. Our mission is to introduce clarity and certainty to complex scientific questions, instilling universal trust in science through transparency, objectivity, and integrity.
Welcome to the Fall 2025 issue of the SciPinion Collective Wisdom Hub. This issue highlights the breadth of SciPinion’s peer review capabilities through three SciPis spanning environmental health, toxicology, and materials science. Experts weigh in on best practices for biomonitoring-based exposure assessments in epidemiology, the cancer mode of action for 1,4-dioxane through a rigorous three-round modified Delphi process, and a rapid critical review of a water soluble film degradation study. Two community polls round out the issue, gathering expert perspectives on the systemic factors behind the United States’ lagging public health outcomes and tracking how scientists’ views on artificial intelligence continue to evolve.
Publications in this Issue:
SciPoll 855: In 2025, AI: Harm or help?
November, 2025
•
10.63565/scipinion.scipoll.855
The third annual SciPinion AI perception poll tracking how experts’ views on artificial intelligence are changing over time. Following rapid advances in model capabilities and widespread commercial deployment, this poll examines expert perspectives on AI’s evolving role in research and academia, including questions about appropriate use, methodological transparency, and maintaining research integrity.
View
View
SciPoll 818: What factors contribute to the United States lagging other countries in public health?
November, 2025
•
10.63565/scipinion.scipoll.818
Despite having one of the world’s largest economies and most advanced medical technologies, the United States ranks below many developed nations in key health metrics including life expectancy, infant mortality, and chronic disease rates. This SciPoll gathers expert input on the root causes of this health paradox and evidence-based strategies to address persistent public health challenges, set against the backdrop of recent MAHA policy discussions.
View
View
SciPi 815: Rapid Review: Study on degradation of water soluble film
October, 2025
•
10.63565/scipinion.scipi.815
SciPinion recruited experts in analytical chemistry and materials science to participate in a rapid-response critical review of a study concerning the degradation of water soluble film. Experts reviewed materials, answered structured questions, and participated in moderated debate to arrive at a collective assessment.
View
View
SciPi 599: 3-Round Modified Delphi Peer Review: Cancer Mode of Action Classification for 1,4-Dioxane
September, 2025
•
10.63565/scipinion.scipi.599
A rigorous three-round modified Delphi peer review examining the cancer mode of action classification for 1,4-dioxane (1,4-DX). An anonymous panel of five expert reviewers evaluated a corpus of six published studies spanning toxicology, risk assessment, and regulatory science to develop a consensus position on the available evidence.
View
View
SciPi 646: Improving Epidemiology Study Designs When Using Biomonitoring for Exposure Assessment
September, 2025
•
10.63565/scipinion.scipi.646
This SciPinion expert panel was assembled to develop best practices for the use of biomonitoring data in exposure assessments in epidemiology studies, with a particular focus on addressing within- and between-individual variability. The panel’s findings aim to improve the validity and interpretability of epidemiological research that relies on biomonitoring measurements.
View
View